Psychotherapy

Therapy Is a Real Relationship

Being a person is embarrassing. So much of what is required to be a person in the world, and in relationship to others, takes such bravery and belief. Therapy ups the ante of that a thousandfold. (Is that an exaggeration? Maybe. In any case, it ups the ante quite a bit.) To get the most out of therapy, people are asked to be open, vulnerable, and willing to share their deepest struggles, sadnesses, and fears with someone who is trained to be with them on their journey, but who is also a person who, given the premise of this essay, is embarrassing.

This is the first in a series of essays about the therapeutic relationship: what it is, what it asks of both people in the room, and why, in a relational psychodynamic practice like ours, it is not the setting for the work but the work itself.

Is the therapy relationship a real relationship?

The therapeutic relationship is designed to be unique and sacred. There are legal and ethical parameters built into it that make it protective and set it apart from other relationships. But those same parameters can make it seem as though the relationship exists outside of authenticity, or lacks the genuine nature of a “real” relationship.

Why you pay someone to listen

It is easy to see how that happens. Those who seek therapy may have friends who are good listeners, but they do not often (ever?) have to pay those friends to listen, beyond the occasional meal. So it seems important to acknowledge that fee for service does place it outside what a normal relationship requires. The therapist is paid because they are trained to do more than listen as a friend would. They hear what is behind what is being said, hold the whole of the client’s story and experience in mind, and make the connections and interpretations that help a client know themselves better, and know how to be themselves, in relationship with themselves and others, in ways that feel clearer and healthier.

What the frame is for

The therapist needs to hold the frame of the therapeutic relationship so that the person seeking their help is emotionally and physically safe to explore their intrapsychic and interpersonal struggles. If things come up for the therapist within that relationship, it is their duty to take them to their own therapist or to consultation with a colleague, so that they are not working them out in the therapeutic environment.

Still a real relationship

The therapeutic relationship, if it holds the frame, keeps the best interest of the client in mind, and honors the dignity in the client as well as the therapist, is still a real relationship. It is still, in its way, a relationship between two (or more) embarrassing people. The therapist is, hopefully, a well trained embarrassing person, and the client a brave embarrassing person. What develops between them in their professional relationship is honest and sincere caring, and a desire for a connection that brings help and healing to the client.

A practical note, since this is a practice website

I should say, since this is a practice website and not a journal, that this is how we work at Coastal Therapy Group. Every clinician here holds a doctorate and works relationally, which is a technical way of saying that what happens between the two people in the room is taken seriously, as part of the work rather than an interruption to it. Whether this kind of therapy is for you is hard to know in the abstract (most people find out by sitting down with someone), which is the reason for the free 15-minute consultation. My colleagues see people in Carlsbad, Encinitas, and Vista; I see people in Pasadena and online, as do several of us throughout California. If you would like a plainer version of this essay, there is a guide to the therapeutic relationship. And if you are ready to be brave, here is where to start.

Common questions about the therapy relationship

Does my therapist actually care about me?

In a good therapy relationship, yes. The care is real; it is just shaped differently than a friend's care. A therapist is trained to hold your whole story in mind, to hear what sits behind what you are saying, and to keep the relationship organized around your interest rather than their own. The fee and the boundaries do not cancel the caring. They are what make it safe to offer.

Is the relationship with a therapist a real relationship?

It is. It has legal and ethical parameters that other relationships do not, and those can make it feel as though it exists outside of ordinary authenticity. But what develops between a client and a therapist who holds the frame well is honest, sincere, and particular to the two of you. It is, in its way, a relationship between two people who are both doing something brave.

Why do I have to pay a therapist if they care about me?

Because listening is not the service. A therapist is paid to hear what is underneath what is being said, to hold the whole of your experience in mind across months, and to make the connections and interpretations that help you know yourself better. The fee also protects you: it keeps the relationship about your needs rather than the therapist's, and it is part of what sets the room apart from everything else in your life.

What does it mean that a therapist holds the frame?

The frame is the structure around the work: the set time, the private room, confidentiality, the fee, and the therapist's commitment to keep their own reactions out of your hour. A therapist who holds the frame makes the room emotionally and physically safe enough to explore things you cannot explore anywhere else. If something comes up for the therapist, they take it to their own therapist or a consulting colleague, not to you.

Is it normal to feel embarrassed in therapy?

Yes. Therapy asks you to say out loud, in front of someone, the things you usually keep to yourself. That takes bravery, and the feeling of exposure usually eases as trust builds. If the embarrassment is getting in the way, say so in the room. It is often the most useful thing you can bring to a session.

Thinking about starting therapy?

If this essay resonated, a conversation might help more. Reach out for a free 15-minute consultation. Our care coordinator will match you with the right therapist, with no pressure and no obligation.

Book a free consultation
Free 15-min consult Call